A brief post, mostly made to remember the DELICIOUS menu the man and I prepared for our weird Thanksgiving 2020.
The day was of course totally different from normal years, but the two of us (and Lola cat) managed to have a fun time doing things like:
- Playing Outburst (Lola demonstrating her technique below)
- Watching the parade/dog show (my boyfriend loses his mind at dog shows, who knew?!)
- Zooming/facetiming with our respective families
- Going for a walk and hardcore judging the mob of 17 (!) unmasked people who walked by us
- Snacking N’s delicious deviled eggs
- Cooking lots
And then after our cooking was done we ate. And ate. And ate. And ate.
- N bought a smoked turkey breast and made it using this technique. I’d never had a smoked turkey breast and holy cow it was great. I am usually deeply indifferent to Thanksgiving turkey but I went back for seconds on this.
- N also made gravy. He said he was watching a morning television Best Thanksgiving Side Dishes bracket and said he was very disappointed that the two finalists were stuffing and rolls. So I said, “Well what is your favorite Thanksgiving side dish?” And he said “Gravy!” lolol.
- The best mashed sweet potatoes from Serious Eats which really did live up to their name. Roasting for two hours seemed a bit silly but it was totally hands off and they were melty and dreamy when they came out, and then with the flavor of the brown butter and thyme, holy cow. Note that I skipped the maple syrup because they were plenty sweet. Also note that I roasted the sweet potatoes 2-3 days in advance with no ill effects.
- Two-bread stuffing that I chose because it won this recipe show down. I made the cornbread the week before Thanksgiving, then froze it. Two days before Thanksgiving, I let it and the regular sandwich bread (I used the last bits of all kinds of random bread loaves including a few flaky breakfast pastries) sit out overnight and stale. Then the day before Thanksgiving I sauteed the veggies and herbs and things and mixed them up with the torn up bread and the broth and let them sit overnight. Baked on Thanksgiving day, hands off. Super easy.
- Smitten Kitchen’s homemade from scratch green bean casserole. I used Trader Joe’s frozen haricots verts rather than fresh green beans, and didn’t bother blanching. Made both components the day before and kept the onions out, at room temperature, just loosely covered by the paper towel. I heated up the green beans bit til hot and bubbly and then baked the onions on top for 10-15 minutes. N usually doesn’t like green bean casserole but got seconds on this.
- Cranberry sauce which I as usual just winged. In a little saucepan I threw together a bag of fresh cranberries, a small pear chopped up, maybe 1 T grated fresh ginger, maybe 1/4 c maple syrup, and maybe 1/4 c sugar. Cooked til it looked like cranberry sauce haha.
It was a rather beautiful and colorful plate. N got this artsy shot.
As for the dessert department…
- N made chocolate pudding pie, for which he considerably amped up the chocolate intensity by making the pudding using, instead of regular milk, a mix of chocolate milk, evaporated milk, and sweetened condensed milk. With beautiful chocolate shavings atop the cream.
- N also made pumpkin pie. Again he went rogue on the filling and used a mix of sweetened condensed milk and evaporated milk, and put in both pumpkin pie spice and additional cinnamon and nutmeg.
- I made this bittersweet chocolate bourbon pecan pie that was seriously the best pecan pie I have ever tasted. I mostly followed the recipe but diverted in a few ways 1. I used browned butter instead of melted butter because yes please. 2. Instead of chocolate chips I chopped up 1.5 Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Lovers 85% Dark Chocolate Bars because it they are super intense and delicious and thought the really bitter chocolate would nicely play off the intense sweetness of the filling. 3. I blind baked the crust at 425 degrees for ten minutes before filling, because I wanted to avoid a soggy bottom. Oh also I used a little bit of agave syrup in the filling because I didn’t have quite enough corn syrup but I don’t think that did anything too dramatic! It was freaking unreal. Note that you definitely taste the bourbon! Maybe not a great pie for kids haha.
I had maybe 1/4 to 1/2 slice of each pie on Thanksgiving itself but in the following days I have had pie for breakfast each day and a worrying number of additional servings haha. This is what happens when you make three pies for two people! I’ve been foisting off leftovers like crazy.